By Rev. Mindi Welton-Mitchell
The Baptist movement began in the early 17th century as a movement of free will: if one is already born into a church, how can they be free to choose Christ as their savior? Our ancestors in the Baptist movement wrestled with this question in England and in New England, this idea that we must consciously choose to know Jesus Christ as our savior and that our church membership must be voluntary, a movement known as Congregationalism. This Congregationalism is part of our Congregational Polity – the freedom of each congregation to make its own decisions in terms of membership, leadership, order its own worship and governance, and discerning the local church’s theology.
However, when Congregationalism came to New England in the form of Puritanism (“purifying” the church) the Massachusetts Bay Colony was established with what became known as the Congregational Church in authority. Roger Williams, first an Anglican priest, then a Puritan minister (Congregationalist) argued against the church controlling the local government. At that time, people living in Massachusetts were required to pay a portion of taxes to the church. Roger Williams was banished from Massachusetts, but he fled to what is now Rhode Island with the help of the Wampanoag people, and established a colony without church control. The separation of church and state became the founding principle of Rhode Island, and of the First Baptist Church that Williams established.
This concept of free will leads us in our Baptist principles. If there was one descriptive word for Baptists, it would be the word freedom:
Church Freedom: each local church is free to determine its membership, call and ordain ministers, order its worship and business, and determine its doctrine.
Religious Freedom: everyone ought to be free to worship God without control by the government, and the government should not be controlled by the church. This principle helped guide the movement that led to the First Amendment: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”
Bible Freedom: Believers are free to read the Bible and interpret Scripture directly with guidance from the Holy Spirit and with the best scholarly tools available.
Soul Freedom: each person is free to worship God without the imposition of a priest, with guidance from the Holy Spirit and how their conscience directs them.
Our Baptist principles helped guide the foundation of religious freedom in this country. However, they are under attack. From groups that want to reinstate state-sponsored prayer or the posting of the Ten Commandments in public schools, to using Christian themes and taking scripture out of context to justify our country going to war, to federal agents entering church spaces—all of this reminds us of why it is important to not only know our Baptist principles, but to speak out for them. To speak out for the religious freedom of all people, because we know our own religious liberty may be threatened. To speak out against government overreach into our religious spaces, because it may be used against any religious group. To speak out against Christianity being sponsored or used in a way that coerces religious minorities and those of no religion to conform.
Our Baptist principles are based in freedom, in the idea that we must be free to worship as guided by the Holy Spirit, to relate to God directly without the imposition of any authority. Our Baptist principles also remind us that we hold our liberties in tension at times. Recently, the American Baptist Churches, USA was part of litigation against the federal government to block ICE agents from entering worship spaces as sensitive spaces, so that all may be free to worship without fear. We have some churches that specifically asked that their church be withdrawn from this litigation. As much as I believe this litigation protects our churches and their very freedom, I also must respect the autonomy of the local church to make its own decisions.
At times, as a region or denominational body, we may make decisions that your church disagrees with. From the very beginning, with the organization of the Philadelphia Baptist Association in 1707, there has been disagreement and dissension. This is part of our history. We may make decisions as a denominational body, but local churches are not bound to them. There is room for disagreement, but yet we stay united under Christ. Sometimes, a church makes a decision to leave the denomination, and we grieve for that separation. However, we are discovering more churches wanting to join with American Baptists because of our diversity, because we do not conform, but choose to join together as one body, with many members (Romans 12:4-5).
This is what I love about being American Baptist. You and I do not have to think alike to love alike. There’s an old saying that “wherever two Baptists are gathered, there are at least three opinions” (sometimes we add “and there’s a casserole for the potluck”).
If you would like to learn more about our Baptist principles, our history, and our polity, as well as your own church’s history and how your church fits into this misfit family known as Baptists, I invite you to join us for Baptist History and Polity this spring. This class was originally designed for ministers seeking ordination, but last fall we had other lay members take the course and we found that everyone benefits from learning more. We will be offering the class in a hybrid format (meaning you can join us online or in person), and the in-person locations will be at various churches in the region so you can learn a little more about that church’s history. Join us for Tuesday evenings in April and May. Click here to learn more and to register.
